Saturday, July 15, 2006

Towards a Meaningful Ordering of Hands

Overview

Many poker books include chapters with hand rankings, and many software tools (including some at propokertools.com) support specifying the top N% of hands. Almost immediately the question arises - how do we create a meaningful ordering of hands?

One possibility is to use human judgement in creating hand rankings. This has worked fairly well in strategy books on hold'em, partly because the game is reasonably well understood, and partly because there are only a small number of distinct hold'em hands (169 to be exact). For omaha, it is not practical to list all the hands in a chart, as there are 16,432 distinct hands. Some authors have come up with point systems for evaluating omaha hand strength, and others have given general guidelines.

A second possibility is to race each possible hand against a set of random hands (say, two or three). Up until recently, propokertools.com used this approach. It is very easy to generate an ordering this way with less than a hundred lines of computer code, and the result will have no human biases. Upon inspection, however, the results leave something to be desired. This is not surprising, as random hands are rarely played in practice.

A third possibility is described by Billings, Davidson, Schaeffer and Szafron in "The challenge of poker" (a paper in "Artificial Intelligence"). At propokertools.com, we use hand orderings inspired by their approach. We created an evolutionary computer simulation, whereby the set of "good hands" is gradually refined, and hands are ranked against other "good hands".

The Evolution Program

To generate the ordering for each game:

Perform the following computation a total of ten times:
For each possible hand h:
Do the following many times (where "many" doubles each iteration):
  • Deal the hand h, and add one chip to the pot

  • Deal one random hand b, and add one chip to the pot (to simulate a "blind" hand)

  • Deal eight random hands. For each "good" hand (defined later), add one chip to the pot (to simulate a player calling). For all the rest, fold the hand

  • Deal a board, and award the pot to the winner(s)
We define a "good" hand as one which, on average, wins more than one chip from the pot. Put another way, a "good" hand is one that does better than break-even. For the first iteration, all hands are considered "good" hands. As the simulation is run, the set of good hands shrinks, and by the seventh iteration or so it becomes fairly stable.

Some Interesting Results

Top 15 hands by game
  • Hold'em : AA, KK, QQ, JJ, AKs, TT, AKo, AQs, 99, AJs

  • Omaha hi (all double suited): AAJJ, AATT, AAQQ, AAJT, AA55, AAKK, AA44, AA66, AA99, AA77

  • Omaha hi/lo: AxAy2x3y, AxAy2x4y, AxAy2x5y, AxAy2x2y, AxAy3x4y, AxAy2z3x, AxAy2x6y, AxAy2x3z, AxAy3x5y, AxAy2z4x
Speaking subjectively, these results look pretty good to me. For hold'em, I might put AQo ahead of AJs. For omaha, the numerical results are very close - this is not surprising given the relatively large set of hands possible. A small bit of random variation could easily have moved some hands up or down a few spots.

Percentage of "good" hands by game after the last iteration
  • Hold'em: 13% of hands are "good" (last "good" hand is KJo)

  • Omaha hi: 15% of hands are "good" (last "good" hand is QxQyJz3x)

  • Omaha hi/lo: 15.5% of hands are "good" (last "good" hand is AxJxTx4x)

Profitability of "best" hand by game
  • Hold'em: AA rates 2.046

  • Omaha hi: AAJJ double suited rates 1.568

  • Omaha hi/lo: AA23 double suited rates 1.571

Limitations of this Approach

As with any approach based on all hands going to river, caution must be used when interpreting the results. Furthermore, as our method uses random results, the generated orderings will be different each time our evolution program is run. In the future we will be performing experiments to see how much variation there is from run to run. We also plan on running the evolution program for games with less than 10 players to see what differences arise.

10 Comments:

At 3:00 PM, Blogger M said...

Very nice approach. Waiting for new results.

 
At 2:44 PM, Blogger Fritz said...

Many poker books include chapters with hand rankings, and many software tools (including some at propokertools.com) support specifying the ... 4hand-tools.blogspot.com

 
At 3:56 AM, Blogger Jason statham said...

Never found such informative articles bandar qiu qiu

 
At 7:55 AM, Blogger Unknown said...

Your blog looks very cool. Play with online casino malaysia for best Malaysian live casino experience. For Online live casino Malaysia, slot game Malaysia, Playtech casino, Online live casino Malaysia, Online betting Malaysia it's the best option.

 
At 6:41 PM, Blogger sothea hy said...


i Never found Related Articles ,website gclub.
gclub casino online
casino online
gclub online

 
At 3:28 AM, Blogger samia hussain said...

nice post

 
At 2:42 PM, Blogger christy alexander said...



Kini sudah hadir DewaDominoQQ untuk para pecinta domino dan poker online. Oleh karna itu , DewaDominoQQ hadir dengan website poker yang dapat dimainkan dengan transaksi menggunakan uang asli rupiah dengan proses deposit dan withdraw yang kurang dari 5 menit.

Selain itu di DewaDominoQQ telah menyediakan berbagai permainan berbeda lainnya yang bisa dimainkan dengan mudah hanya menggunakan 1 ID, yaitu ;
1. Poker
2. Bandar poker
3. Capsa susun
4. Domino 99
5. Adu Q
6. Bandar Q
7. Bandar Sakong
8. Fish Hunting --- www.gg626.com
9. Cock Fight --- www.s128.net

Para pecinta poker online juga dijamin tidak akan kecewa karena DewaDominoQQ juga memiliki banyak keuntungan dan keunggulan tersendiri jelas berbeda dari agen lainnya, yaitu ;
1. Permainan yang Anda mainkan di DewaDominoQQ adalah Poker Fair Play.
2. Poker tidak menggunakan sistem robot atau asli Real Player vs Real Player.
3. Proses transaksi Deposit dan juga Withdraw yang cepat.
4. Kami juga telah menyediakan 6 bank ternama di Indonesia, seperti bank BCA, MANDIRI, BNI, BRI, CIMB, dan DANAMON supaya para pecinta poker online dapat dengan mudah melakukan transaksi.
5. Dilayani CS yang ramah dan profesional, yang siap melayani para member setia DewaDominoQQ selama 24jam full.
6. Bonus Referral sebesar 20% yang akan dibagikan pada hari Senin secara cuma - cuma kepada para member yang mengajak teman-teman untuk bermain bersama kami di DewaDominoQQ.
7. Bonus TurnOver sebesar 0,5% yang di bagikan setiap hari Senin juga untuk member-member setia DewaDominoQQ.
8. Hanya dengan Minimum deposit 15000 dan Minimun withdraw 15000 !!!

Mari buruan daftarkan diri Anda dan jadilah member setia untuk bermain di DewaDominoQQ, dan jangan lupa untuk mengajak teman-teman anda untuk bermain di DewaDominoQQ. Rasakan bonus dan sensasinya bermain poker tanpa sistem robot hanya bersama kami di DewaDominoQQ.

Ayo buruan mendaftar sebelum ketinggalan hadiah Jackpot dan uang tunai ratusan juta rupiah !!!

Contact WA : +85593827759
BBM : 2B5E9CDB

 
At 5:56 AM, Blogger Tikus Got said...

NAGAQQASIA.COM | NAGAQQ ASIA | AGEN BANDARQ | BANDARQ ONLINE | BANDARPOKER ONLINE | DOMINOQQ

Kami ingin mengajak anda buat bergabung dan bermain bersama kami di NagaQQAsia

Agen resmi : POKER ,DOMINOQQ ,BANDARQ , dan BANDAR POKER TERBESAR DI ASIA

Kelebihan NagaQQAsia Agen POKER ,DOMINOQQ ,BANDARQ , dan BANDAR POKER Online Indonesia Terbesar di Asia:
* Minimal deposit hanya Rp 15rb
* Minimal Withdraw hanya Rp 20rb
* Deposit dan withdraw 24 jam
* Bonus Refferral seumur hidup tanpa syarat
* Bonus Rollingan setiap minggu nya.
* Hanya Dengan 1 ID Anda Bisa Bermain dengan 4 Game Sekaligus

Contact Us :
+++ Website : NagaQQAsia
+++ Phone : +855967014811
+++ BBM : 2B209F68
+++ YM : nagaqq
+++ WeChat : nagaqq
+++ Live Chat 24 Jam ^^

Facebook : NagaQQASIA
Twitter : NagaQQ01
Instagram : Naga_QQ

Segera Daftarkan Diri Anda dan Sobat-Sobatmu Untuk Bermain BANDARQ, Domino99, BandarPoker dan Poker Online.

 
At 5:56 AM, Blogger Vania Rilisia said...

CROWNQQ | CROWNQQ.COM | AGEN DOMINOQQ | BANDARQ | SAKONG | DOMINO99 ONLINE TERBESAR

Kami ingin mengajak anda buat bergabung dan bermain bersama kami di CrownQQ

Agen resmi : POKER ,DOMINOQQ ,BANDARQ ,CAPSA SUSUN ,ADUQ ,SAKONG dan BANDAR POKER TERBESAR DI ASIA

Kelebihan CrownQQ Agen POKER ,DOMINOQQ ,BANDARQ ,CAPSA SUSUN ,ADUQ ,SAKONG, BANDAR POKER Online Indonesia Terbesar di Asia:
* Minimal deposit hanya Rp 20rb
* Minimal Withdraw hanya Rp 20rb
* Deposit dan withdraw 24 jam
* Bonus Refferral 20 % seumur hidup tanpa syarat
* Bonus Rollingan 0,5 % setiap minggu nya.
* Hanya Dengan 1 ID Anda Bisa Bermain dengan 7 Game Sekaligus

Contact Us :
+++ Website : CrownQQ
+++ Phone / WA : +855967646513
+++ BBM : 2B382398
+++ YM : Cs.CrownQQ
+++ FB FANPAGE : CrownQQ1
+++ TWITTER : Crown_QQ
+++ IG : Crown_QQ
+++ TUMBLR : CrownQQ
+++ VK : CrownQQ

Segera Daftarkan Diri Anda dan Sobat-Sobatmu Untuk Bermain BANDARQ,Domino99 dan Poker Online.

 
At 9:34 AM, Blogger Unknown said...

Amazing collection of casino games. I really Love your snap for online casino experience. You also can try your fortune with play online casino Malaysia today. The best part of casino site is it offers the variety of game and which can play any part of the world. It's very handy to use.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home